After Dark
Conspiracy
About Conspiracy
Conspiracy is a welcoming nightlife destination at 350 Main St in Middletown, CT, offering an inviting setting for a relaxed drink, a casual meal, or an enjoyable evening out. With a 4.50 out of 5 rating from 488 customer reviews, it has earned strong recognition from the people who visit.
Its atmosphere brings together casual comfort, cozy surroundings, romantic touches, trendy style, and an upmarket feel, making it a versatile choice for different occasions and dining preferences.
Guests can enjoy table service along with a full selection of alcohol, beer, cocktails, spirits, and food, including food served at the bar. Happy-hour drinks and happy-hour food provide additional ways to make the most of a visit, while great cocktails and fast service help create a smooth and enjoyable experience.
Live music and live performances add energy to the setting, whether you are meeting friends, planning a date, or choosing a spot for solo dining. For added convenience, Conspiracy accepts reservations and offers delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options.
Accessibility and practical amenities are also part of the experience, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible toilet available for guests. Restroom facilities are provided, and payment is convenient through credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
To learn more or make plans, call **+1 860-236-0211** or visit Conspiracy at **350 Main St, Middletown, CT 06457, United States**.
Live Music
Top DJs and live acts
Craft Cocktails
Premium drink menu
VIP Service
Exclusive experiences
Events
Themed nights weekly
The Experience
Your Night Awaits
Premium Bar
Craft cocktails, top-shelf spirits, and an extensive wine list crafted by expert mixologists.
Dance Floor
State-of-the-art sound system and lighting that transforms every night into magic.
VIP Lounge
Exclusive bottle service and private areas for those seeking a more intimate experience.
About Us
Where Nights Come Alive
Whether it's a night out with friends, a celebration, or simply letting loose, we're here to make it unforgettable.
The Vibe
See what awaits you tonight
What People Say
Reviews from our guests
Santos Shetty
4 years agoAlways come here if you are at Wesleyan University. Post Covid visit I’m very glad to see them doing extremely well. Their focus is mainly on pre prohibition classics but they’ve added a lot more tikki and floral notes which can be found in the back of the book. Cocktails are just absolutely superb and expressive of the notes. Had the After eight old fashioned, Black Album, High Garden, Night Shade and St. Marks. All of them were exceptional
Claire Pawlewitz
3 years agoLate at night the lighting is dim and the atmosphere is quiet and fantastic. A phenomenal place to get great classic cocktails as well as extensive seasonal cocktail selections - ALSO all the drinks are listed on cards in a deck of tarot looking cards 😍 …
Hoosieronthemove
2 years agoThis was my second time coming here this year, and I’m in love. I knew they have a tarot card deck of drinks and I finally got to try one. The drink I got tasted just like a fluffernutter and let me tell you, I would have ordered like 3 of this if I didn’t have to drive home, they were so tasty. Love the ambiance in here, they have really good bites to eat as well.
Rebecca Taddei
4 years agoWow! First time visit tonight, and this place is a gem. I had a hard time deciding which unique drink to order, but the end result was worth it. Also, vegan cali-dog was delicious! My friend ordered the bartender's choice, and it was a perfect match for him. The bartender was fantastic and friendly! Thanks so much, we'll definitely be back! Update: The campfire old fashion set makes a wonderful gift! Picked one up for a friend and they loved it!
Jp
5 years agoIt’s difficult to put into words how much I love this place. The bartenders are incredible, attentive, and accommodating. The bar gets really busy at times but they make sure to keep checking in. The drink menu is always changing and one of a kind. I’ve never had drinks like this at another bar in the area. It’s a beautiful bar with a great speakeasy atmosphere. The cocktails are unique and delicious. They are always coming up with new ideas and fun ventures. This is by far one of my favorite bars in CT.
Chris Rakoczy
year agoAscend the narrow staircase into a higher realm of cocktails. If you enjoy quality cocktails with unique flavor profiles and ingredients, this is the place for you. Tucked up on a second floor in the heart of the wonderful downtown Middletown, Conspiracy leans towards classic and Prohibition era spirits crafted for sipping, savoring, and indulging. The food menu includes some similarly interesting items, but really, you are here for the cocktails. We had the Campfire Old Fashioned, (fashioned with bourbon, smoked maple and a toasted marshmallow), the World (a spherical glass with a decadent blend of ginger and bourbon with notes of cranberry and orange smoothed out by a luxurious white chocolate), and a High Priestess (hibiscus infused gin and other flavors I can't identify!) All were layered and nuanced in flavor. This is a place you have to return to to try all the options. These aren't the sorts of flavors you get anywhere else!
Scott D
4 weeks agoI love this hideaway. The food is pretty good for snacks too. Of course the drinks are exemplary.
Greg Roberge
2 months agothis was maybe my 3rd or 4th time here, it's always such a a great vibe. The drinks are bespoke and the price reflects that but it's always worth it. I have not been disappointed yet with the complex flavors and creative menus. For example the Pride menu was . absolutely Brilliant 🌟
Lindsey Shellman
2 months agoJust found this place and omg so glad we did. Stefano took care of us and he was amazing. I had two different bartenders selections - you tell him what your preferences are and he works his magic. My husband loved his drinks and mine were fantastic. We will be back and we will be regulars. Hidden gem unlocked.
Jaden McDonnell
5 months agoBest drinks in Middletown, maybe even Connecticut, NYC quality with CT pricing. Conspiracy is locally owned by a husband and wife. They have found the perfect combination between delicious and creative. Their menu changes about every month which is crafted by the owner and bartenders. You never know what will be on the menu but you can guarantee you will like something. One drink that stuck out to me was a pumpkin chai inspired drink served in an edible cup! A fun move here is ordering the Bartender’s Choice. You tell them your preferred spirit and flavor profile, and they improvise a custom cocktail on the spot. They also offer a food menu but the drinks are the real reason to come here. The food is impressive for their kitchen size but don’t expect a meal here. They offer a happy hour 5-7 and live music on the weekends. The vibe is intimate, dim light with quiet music, perfect for a good conversation. Their location can be hard to find, but look closely for this hidden gem as you walk down Main Street in Middletown. I’d genuinely challenge someone to find a better cocktail bar in CT.
Popular Items
Menu Highlights
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Conspiracy
Food & Drinks
Menu & Prices
Entrees
Assorted veggies with fresh bread and mustard.
Roasted peaches, arugula, strawberry balsamic drizzle and olive oil.
Sammies
Cheddar, fig, jam and prosciutto. Served with housemade chips.
Guacamole, pico and Mexican cheddar blend. Served with housemade chips.
Cheddar, fig, jam and prosciutto. Served with housemade chips.
Waffles
Light, airy with choice of syrup. Choose a syrup: Local Maple Syrup, Bourbon Maple Syrup, Lyle's Cane Syrup, Agave Syrup, Honey Sriracha Syrup
Oreos, cocoa and cream cheese frosting.
Cheese
New England cheeses. Served with fresh bread, fig jam, local honey, pistachios and quince. Choose a first cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese. Choose a second cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese. Choose a third cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese
New England cheeses. Served with fresh bread, fig jam, local honey, pistachios and quince. Choose a first cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese. Choose a second cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese. Choose a third cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese. Choose a fourth cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese. Choose a fifth cheese: Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddar Cheese, Grafton Cheddar 2 Year Cheese, Jasper Hill Moses Sleeper Cheese, Cato Bridgid's Abbey Cheese, Cato Hooligan Cheese, Cato Corner Womanchego Cheese, Cato Corner Bloomsday Cheese, Arethusa Diva Cheese, Arethusa Mt. Tom Cheese, Arethusa Europa Cheese, Arethusa Blue Cheese, Arethusa Tapping Reeve Cheddar Cheese, Vermont Creamery Goat Cheese, Tartentaise Comte Cheese, Fiddelhead Tomme Cheese, Beaverbrook Nehantic Abbey Cheese, Plain Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Smoked Green Teas Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese, Truffle Dr. Cow Brooklyn Vegan Cheese
Menu Photos
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Conspiracy
- Sunday: 3 PM-12 AM
- Monday: 5 PM-1 AM
- Tuesday: Closed
- Wednesday: 5 PM-1 AM
- Thursday: 5 PM-1 AM
- Friday: 5 PM-2 AM
- Saturday: 5 PM-2 AM
Conspiracy is located at 350 Main St, Middletown, CT 06457, United States, Middletown, CT, United States.
You can reach Conspiracy by calling +1 860-236-0211.
Conspiracy has a rating of 4.5 out of 5 based on 488 customer reviews.
Conspiracy features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible toilet, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Conspiracy features the following service options: Delivery, Takeaway, Dine-in.
Conspiracy features the following highlights: Fast service, Great cocktails, Live music, Live performances.
Conspiracy features the following popular for: Solo dining.
Conspiracy features the following offerings: Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Food, Food at bar, Happy-hour drinks, Happy-hour food, Spirits, Wine.
Conspiracy features the following dining options: Table service.
Conspiracy features the following amenities: Restroom.
Conspiracy features the following atmosphere: Casual, Cozy, Romantic, Trendy, Upmarket.
Conspiracy features the following crowd: Groups.
Conspiracy features the following planning: Accepts reservations.
Conspiracy features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Conspiracy features the following parking: Free street parking, Paid parking lot, Paid street parking, Somewhat difficult to find a space.
Business Features
Highlights & Amenities
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great cocktails
- Live music
- Live performances
Popular for
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Food
- Food at bar
- Happy-hour drinks
- Happy-hour food
- Spirits
- Wine
Dining options
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Romantic
- Trendy
- Upmarket
Crowd
- Groups
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Parking
- Free street parking
- Paid parking lot
- Paid street parking
- Somewhat difficult to find a space
Find Us
Ready to experience the best night out? We're waiting for you.
Location
350 Main St, Middletown, CT 06457, United StatesPhone
+1 860-236-0211Hours
Make a Reservation
VIP tables, group bookings, and private events. Get in touch.